Have you ever played "Would You Rather?" It's a super fun game where you're given two not-so-easy choices and you have to pick which one you'd rather do. Well, guess what? You can totally play "Would You Rather" with church stuff too! These "Would You Rather Questions For Church" can be a great way to get people thinking, laughing, and even having some interesting conversations about faith and what matters most. They're not meant to be tricky, but rather to spark some imagination and friendly debate.
What Are "Would You Rather Questions For Church" and Why Are They Awesome?
So, what exactly are "Would You Rather Questions For Church"? Think of them as fun prompts that present you with two slightly challenging or thought-provoking situations related to church life, faith, or Christian values. For example, instead of just asking "Do you like hymns?", a "Would You Rather" question might be: "Would you rather only be able to sing hymns at church or only be able to listen to contemporary worship songs?" They work because they tap into our natural tendency to consider options and make choices. They're popular because they're interactive and can lead to unexpected and often humorous discussions. It's a low-stakes way to explore different perspectives.
The best part about these kinds of questions is how they're used. They can be perfect for:
- Icebreakers at youth group or Bible study
- Fun games during church events or retreats
- Conversation starters during fellowship time
- Even just a way to get your own brain thinking about your faith in a new light
The importance of these questions lies in their ability to encourage empathy, open-mindedness, and a deeper understanding of different viewpoints within a faith community. They help us see that there's often more than one way to approach things and that it's okay to have different preferences, as long as we respect each other.
Would You Rather: Worship Styles
- Would you rather only be able to clap during worship songs or only be able to stand with your hands in your pockets?
- Would you rather have the pastor wear a different silly costume every week or have the worship band wear matching polka dot outfits?
- Would you rather only be able to sing super fast songs or only be able to sing super slow songs?
- Would you rather have a spontaneous choir of squirrels join the worship service or have the organ play a different cartoon theme song for each hymn?
- Would you rather have the sermon be exactly one minute long every week or the sermon be two hours long every week?
- Would you rather only be able to worship in your pajamas or only be able to worship in full formal wear?
- Would you rather have the choir always sing slightly off-key or have the soloist always forget half the words?
- Would you rather have the church bulletin always be upside down or have the church bulletin always be in a secret code?
- Would you rather the pastor give the sermon in interpretive dance or the pastor give the sermon by singing opera?
- Would you rather the church be decorated with balloons for every service or the church be decorated with streamers for every service?
- Would you rather only be able to pray out loud or only be able to pray silently?
- Would you rather have a really loud microphone that picks up every little sound or a microphone that's so quiet you can barely hear it?
- Would you rather have the church bells ring for an hour straight every Sunday morning or have the church bells only ring once a year?
- Would you rather have the worship band play only kazoo or only play the triangle?
- Would you rather every announcement be sung like a Broadway musical number or every announcement be delivered as a dramatic poem?
- Would you rather have the candles in the sanctuary flicker non-stop or have the lights in the sanctuary change color randomly?
- Would you rather the entire congregation have to wear matching silly hats for worship or the entire congregation have to wear matching silly glasses?
- Would you rather the sermon be told entirely through sock puppets or the sermon be told entirely through a puppet show with human-sized puppets?
- Would you rather have the worship music be exclusively polka or exclusively country-western?
- Would you rather the church doors always squeak loudly or the church doors always slam shut loudly?
Would You Rather: Acts of Service
- Would you rather spend a whole Saturday cleaning the church grounds or spend a whole Saturday volunteering at a soup kitchen?
- Would you rather knit blankets for the homeless or deliver meals to the elderly?
- Would you rather help build a playground for underprivileged kids or help renovate a community center?
- Would you rather teach Sunday school to preschoolers or mentor teenagers struggling with difficult choices?
- Would you rather organize a food drive for a local pantry or organize a clothing drive for families in need?
- Would you rather visit lonely people in a nursing home or visit children in a hospital?
- Would you rather spend your weekend helping elderly neighbors with chores or spend your weekend tutoring kids who are falling behind in school?
- Would you rather help clean up a local park or help plant trees in a community garden?
- Would you rather volunteer to read to children at the library or volunteer to help out at an animal shelter?
- Would you rather spend time helping set up for church events or spend time helping clean up after church events?
- Would you rather help someone move house for free or help someone with yard work for free?
- Would you rather bake cookies for first responders or write thank-you cards for them?
- Would you rather help out at a free clinic or help out at a local community center?
- Would you rather collect donations for a charity or volunteer your time at the charity?
- Would you rather help elderly people with their grocery shopping or help busy parents with childcare?
- Would you rather volunteer to be a greeter at church every Sunday or volunteer to be a usher every Sunday?
- Would you rather help create care packages for soldiers overseas or help assemble hygiene kits for refugees?
- Would you rather help sort books for a literacy program or help clean and organize a community workshop?
- Would you rather spend a day at a homeless shelter handing out necessities or spend a day at a local food bank distributing food?
- Would you rather help teach someone a new skill, like basic computer skills or simple car maintenance, or help someone learn to read?
Would You Rather: Biblical Scenarios
- Would you rather have been one of Jesus' disciples or one of the wise men who visited him as a baby?
- Would you rather have the faith of Abraham or the wisdom of Solomon?
- Would you rather witness the parting of the Red Sea or witness Jesus walking on water?
- Would you rather be the one who accidentally dropped the lamp in the story of Gideon or the one who told Samson about Delilah?
- Would you rather have lived through the Great Flood on Noah's Ark or been one of the Israelites escaping Egypt?
- Would you rather have the patience of Job or the courage of David?
- Would you rather be the person who found the lost sheep or the person who found the lost coin?
- Would you rather be a scribe copying the Old Testament scriptures or a traveler listening to Jesus' parables firsthand?
- Would you rather have a personal conversation with Moses about the Ten Commandments or a personal conversation with Paul about his missionary journeys?
- Would you rather be the servant who doubled his master's talents in the parable or the servant who buried his talent?
- Would you rather have been present at the Sermon on the Mount or at the Last Supper?
- Would you rather have the strength of Samson (without the haircut issues) or the healing touch of Jesus?
- Would you rather have a dream revealing God's will like Joseph or a vision like Daniel?
- Would you rather be the prodigal son returning home or the father welcoming him back?
- Would you rather have the boldness of Peter when speaking about Jesus or the loyalty of Ruth to Naomi?
- Would you rather be the one who discovered the empty tomb or one of the two on the road to Emmaus?
- Would you rather have the gift of prophecy like Samuel or the gift of encouragement like Barnabas?
- Would you rather be the fisherman who caught so many fish you needed help (Luke 5) or the woman who caught a huge fish that needed two boats (John 21)?
- Would you rather have helped build the Ark with Noah or helped build the tabernacle with Moses?
- Would you rather have been present when Jesus calmed the storm or when he fed the 5,000?
Would You Rather: Church Life Dilemmas
- Would you rather have your church be incredibly small with only a few members or incredibly large with thousands of members?
- Would you rather the church building be super old and historic or super modern and high-tech?
- Would you rather have potlucks with amazing food but always run out or have mediocre food but always have plenty?
- Would you rather have the church nursery be run by strict supervisors or by overly enthusiastic volunteers?
- Would you rather the church have a choir that sings perfectly but is always grumpy or a choir that’s often off-key but always joyful?
- Would you rather have a youth group that is super organized but a bit boring or super fun but a bit chaotic?
- Would you rather your church have a strict dress code for services or no dress code at all?
- Would you rather have the pastor tell jokes that are hilarious but slightly inappropriate or jokes that are wholesome but fall flat?
- Would you rather the church have an amazing coffee station but no snacks or amazing snacks but no coffee?
- Would you rather the church bulletin be extremely detailed and informative or extremely brief and to the point?
- Would you rather have the church parking lot be always full and require a long walk or always have empty spots right at the door?
- Would you rather the church have a tradition of loud, enthusiastic praise or quiet, reflective worship?
- Would you rather have the church always be freezing cold or always be uncomfortably hot?
- Would you rather the church have a fantastic children's ministry but a weak adult ministry, or vice versa?
- Would you rather your church have a leader who is very strict but effective or very relaxed but less effective?
- Would you rather have the church have potlucks where everyone brings their signature dish, even if it's a bit weird, or potlucks where everyone brings the same three dishes?
- Would you rather the church have a beautiful sanctuary but a terrible fellowship hall or a drab sanctuary but an amazing fellowship hall?
- Would you rather have your church host incredibly long services with no breaks or incredibly short services with no time to connect?
- Would you rather the church always have a different guest speaker every week or always have the same pastor preach?
- Would you rather have your church be known for its incredible music or its incredible community outreach?
Would You Rather: Faith & Personal Choices
- Would you rather have the ability to speak in every language or the ability to understand every animal?
- Would you rather have the gift of perfect memory or the gift of instant learning?
- Would you rather be able to always know the right thing to say or always know the right thing to do?
- Would you rather have the faith to move mountains or the wisdom to know which mountains to move?
- Would you rather be able to instantly forgive anyone who wronged you or always remember every lesson learned from mistakes?
- Would you rather have the courage to stand up for what's right even when it's scary or the patience to wait for the perfect moment to act?
- Would you rather have a quiet, consistent faith that never wavers or a passionate, sometimes turbulent faith that inspires others?
- Would you rather be known for your kindness or your boldness in sharing your faith?
- Would you rather have the ability to inspire great hope in others or the ability to bring deep peace to troubled hearts?
- Would you rather always know the answer to spiritual questions or always have more questions to explore?
- Would you rather be able to influence people towards good deeds through your example or through your words?
- Would you rather have the strength to endure any hardship or the ability to find joy in any circumstance?
- Would you rather always see the best in people or always see the lessons in difficult situations?
- Would you rather have the ability to pray for anything and have it instantly granted or have the ability to pray for understanding and receive it instantly?
- Would you rather be known as a peacemaker or a truth-teller?
- Would you rather have a deep understanding of scripture or a deep understanding of human nature?
- Would you rather be able to share your faith through art and music or through service and action?
- Would you rather have the ability to listen perfectly to anyone's problems or the ability to offer perfect advice to anyone's problems?
- Would you rather always feel God's presence strongly or always feel confident in His promises even when you don't feel it?
- Would you rather be able to inspire millions with your faith or inspire one person deeply every day?
Would You Rather: Church Snacks & Fellowship
- Would you rather have an endless supply of your favorite cookies but they are always slightly stale or perfectly fresh cookies that you only get once a month?
- Would you rather have the best coffee in town at church but no food or the best donuts in town at church but no coffee?
- Would you rather every potluck dish be incredibly delicious but also incredibly spicy or every dish be bland but perfectly safe for everyone?
- Would you rather have church snacks that are healthy and nutritious but taste terrible or delicious but loaded with sugar?
- Would you rather have a fellowship time where everyone talks but no one listens or everyone listens but no one talks?
- Would you rather the church have a tradition of singing grace before every meal or telling a joke before every meal?
- Would you rather have unlimited fancy pastries but they’re all gluten-free and vegan or unlimited classic chocolate chip cookies that some people can’t eat?
- Would you rather have the church have a nacho bar every week or a taco bar every week?
- Would you rather have the coffee station always fully stocked but the tea station always empty or vice versa?
- Would you rather have fellowship time with loud, boisterous games or quiet, thoughtful conversations?
- Would you rather have the church serve only healthy snacks or only desserts?
- Would you rather have a fellowship time where everyone shares their deepest thoughts or everyone shares their funniest jokes?
- Would you rather have the church offer ice cream sundaes every week or freshly baked pies every week?
- Would you rather have the fellowship hall always be decorated with balloons or always be decorated with flowers?
- Would you rather have potluck dishes that are always a surprise, some amazing, some questionable, or potluck dishes that are always reliable but a bit boring?
- Would you rather the church have a popcorn machine that’s always working or a cotton candy machine that’s always working?
- Would you rather have unlimited pizza for fellowship or unlimited sandwiches for fellowship?
- Would you rather have fellowship time where everyone wears silly hats or everyone wears silly ties?
- Would you rather the church serve only homemade treats or only store-bought treats?
- Would you rather have the church have a water fountain that dispenses sparkling water or a juice bar with two options?
Playing "Would You Rather Questions For Church" is a fantastic way to inject some fun and thoughtful engagement into discussions about faith and community. These questions aren't about finding the "right" answer, but about exploring different perspectives and sparking conversations. Whether you're using them for a youth group game, a small group icebreaker, or just for your own personal reflection, they offer a unique and enjoyable way to think about what matters most in our walk of faith and within our church families.