73 Video Game Would You Rather Questions

Ever found yourself staring at your screen, controller in hand, wondering about those crazy "what if" scenarios in your favorite games? That's where Video Game Would You Rather Questions come in! They're a super fun way to dive deep into the worlds we love, forcing us to make tough, hilarious, and sometimes downright impossible choices. Whether you're chatting with friends online or just pondering life's biggest gaming dilemmas, these questions are guaranteed to get you thinking and laughing.

What Exactly Are Video Game Would You Rather Questions?

So, what are these "Video Game Would You Rather Questions" we're talking about? Simply put, they're like those "would you rather" questions you might have heard before, but with a gaming twist! Instead of choosing between eating broccoli or spinach, you're picking between battling a dragon or outsmarting a cunning thief in your favorite RPG, or perhaps deciding if you'd rather have infinite ammo or god-like speed in a shooter. They present two equally appealing (or terrifying!) gaming-related options, and you have to pick one. It's all about exploring the fun, the challenging, and sometimes the downright absurd aspects of the video game universe.

Why are these questions so popular? Well, they tap into our shared experiences as gamers. We all have those moments in games where we wish we had a certain power, or we wonder how we'd handle a specific situation. These questions let us live out those hypotheticals in our minds. They're also fantastic conversation starters. Think about it: arguing with your friends about whether it's better to have the ability to talk to animals in a fantasy game or to teleport across the map in a modern shooter can lead to some epic debates. They're a way to connect with fellow players over the things we love most about gaming.

Here’s how they are used:

Icebreakers: Great for starting conversations with new gaming buddies.
Community Engagement: Many gaming communities use them for polls and discussions.
Content Creation: Streamers and YouTubers often use them for interactive videos.
Personal Reflection: They make you think about your own playstyle and preferences.
Just for Fun: Honestly, they're just a blast to answer and discuss!

Classic RPG Dilemmas

Would you rather have the ability to wield any weapon in an RPG, but never be able to cast magic, or be a master mage, but only be able to use daggers?
Would you rather be the hero who slays the dragon and saves the kingdom, but get no recognition, or be the sidekick who gets all the glory but the hero does all the work?
Would you rather have a loyal but cowardly companion who always runs away in a fight, or a brave but incredibly clumsy companion who often messes up missions?
Would you rather be able to understand and speak to all animals, or be able to perfectly mimic any voice you hear?
Would you rather find a legendary sword that’s incredibly powerful but requires your soul to be drained each time you use it, or find a magical amulet that grants you immense luck but makes you incredibly unlucky in your personal life?
Would you rather be cursed to always hear the thoughts of every NPC you meet, or be cursed to never be able to lie to any NPC?
Would you rather have infinite gold but no ability to learn new skills, or have no gold but the ability to learn any skill instantly?
Would you rather be able to fast travel anywhere on the map instantly, but only once a day, or be able to walk at twice your normal speed all the time?
Would you rather have a pet dragon that breathes fire but is also incredibly noisy, or a magical owl that delivers messages perfectly but is also incredibly judgmental?
Would you rather be able to discover every hidden secret on the map with a single touch, or be able to solve any puzzle in the game without any effort?
Would you rather have your character age rapidly and gain wisdom but lose physical strength, or stay eternally young but never gain any experience points?
Would you rather be able to charm any enemy to join your side, but they eventually betray you, or be able to scare any enemy into fleeing, but they always return stronger?
Would you rather have a companion who is a skilled healer but constantly complains, or a companion who is a formidable warrior but talks way too much?
Would you rather be able to explore every dungeon in the game, but never be able to complete a single quest, or be able to complete every quest, but never be able to explore a single dungeon?
Would you rather have your inventory be infinite but all items are slightly damaged, or have a small inventory but all items are pristine?
Would you rather be able to summon an army of loyal but weak soldiers, or a single, incredibly powerful but uncontrollable warrior?
Would you rather have your character’s backstory be incredibly tragic but empowering, or incredibly mundane but full of happy memories?
Would you rather be able to see the future of your quests, but always have to take the worst possible path, or be able to see the past of your quests, and change one minor detail?
Would you rather have every NPC love you unconditionally, but never give you quests, or have every NPC hate you, but always give you the most lucrative quests?
Would you rather be the most skilled fighter in the land but have no magical abilities, or be the most powerful sorcerer but be physically frail?

FPS Frustrations and Fantasies

Would you rather have infinite ammo but no reload, or have a one-shot kill weapon but have to find ammo for it every single kill?
Would you rather be invisible to enemies but unable to attack, or be able to see enemies through walls but have your weapon jam randomly?
Would you rather have a heartbeat sensor that shows enemy locations, but it also beeps loudly for everyone to hear, or have a radar that shows enemy locations, but it only updates once every minute?
Would you rather have your character sprint at supersonic speeds but have terrible aim, or have perfect aim but only be able to walk at a snail's pace?
Would you rather have a weapon that shoots rubber bullets that do no damage but make enemies laugh uncontrollably, or a weapon that shoots sticky grenades that instantly kill enemies but make your own character move in slow motion?
Would you rather be able to teleport to any point you can see, but each teleport drains 10% of your health, or be able to phase through walls, but only when you're crouching?
Would you rather have your character be able to fly but only when you're standing still, or be able to wall-run but only on specific, marked surfaces?
Would you rather have every enemy you kill drop a random, rare weapon, but they also explode on death, or have every enemy you kill drop a small amount of health, but they all respawn instantly?
Would you rather be able to command any vehicle on the map to follow you, but they are all incredibly slow, or be able to instantly repair any vehicle, but you can only do it once per match?
Would you rather have your character always be equipped with a powerful sniper rifle but never be able to switch weapons, or have a pistol that can shoot anything (lasers, rockets, etc.) but only has 5 shots before needing a recharge?
Would you rather have the ability to turn invisible but your footsteps are extremely loud, or be able to move silently but your weapon makes an incredibly loud noise every time you fire it?
Would you rather have a grenade launcher that shoots bouncy balls that disorient enemies, or a shotgun that shoots confetti that blinds enemies for a few seconds?
Would you rather be able to see enemy weak points but they are always on your own character, or be able to instantly heal any damage taken but you also take double damage from all sources?
Would you rather have a jetpack that allows for incredible vertical movement but has a very short fuel supply, or have boots that grant super jumps but take 30 seconds to recharge?
Would you rather have your character be able to deploy infinite turrets but they are all very weak, or be able to deploy one incredibly powerful turret but it takes 5 minutes to set up?
Would you rather have an enemy AI that is so advanced it can predict your every move, but it’s also incredibly polite and apologizes for attacking you, or an enemy AI that is completely random and incompetent, but it screams obscenities at you?
Would you rather have a shield that blocks all incoming damage but slows you down to a crawl, or a shield that deflects bullets back at enemies but has a small chance of exploding in your face?
Would you rather be able to hack any enemy's weapon to malfunction, but it also makes your own weapon jam, or be able to disable any enemy's HUD, but it also disables your own?
Would you rather have your character be able to throw knives with perfect accuracy, but they always return to your hand like a boomerang, or be able to throw baseballs that explode on impact, but they have a very short throwing range?
Would you rather have a grappling hook that can attach to any surface but only pulls you slowly, or a grappling hook that pulls you instantly but can only attach to specific, glowing anchors?

Platformer Predicaments

Would you rather be able to double jump but only once per level, or triple jump but each jump makes you slightly dizzy?
Would you rather have a dash ability that lets you phase through enemies but not walls, or a wall-climb ability that lets you stick to any surface but you move very slowly?
Would you rather be able to control time to slow down enemies and obstacles, but you also move in slow motion, or be able to rewind time by 5 seconds, but you have to sacrifice a collectible each time?
Would you rather have your character bounce off enemies like a pinball when you jump on them, but you can’t control your direction, or have your character stick to enemies like glue when you jump on them, but you can’t jump off?
Would you rather have a homing jump that automatically targets the nearest platform, but it sometimes misses, or a super jump that takes you incredibly high, but you can’t control your descent?
Would you rather have a magnet ability that pulls you towards coins and collectibles, but it also pulls you towards enemies, or an anti-gravity ability that lets you float upwards, but you’re incredibly vulnerable to wind?
Would you rather have your character move at lightning speed but have very poor jump height, or have incredible jump height but move at a walking pace?
Would you rather be able to swing from any point with a vine, but the vine is always slightly too short, or be able to create temporary platforms, but they disappear after 3 seconds?
Would you rather have your character automatically dodge incoming projectiles, but it’s always a bit too late, or have your character automatically attack any enemy that gets too close, but they also attack your allies?
Would you rather have a special attack that clears the entire screen of enemies, but it takes 30 seconds to charge, or a special attack that instantly defeats one enemy, but you have to defeat 10 enemies before you can use it again?
Would you rather have your character be able to transform into a bouncy ball for a short period, allowing you to roll through tight spaces, or transform into a flying bird, allowing you to glide over gaps?
Would you rather have an infinite supply of throwable items that can stun enemies, but they have a very short range, or have a single, powerful projectile that instantly defeats any enemy, but you can only use it once per level?
Would you rather have your character have suction cups on their feet that allow them to walk on ceilings, but they are very loud, or have their character have sticky hands that allow them to grab ledges from a distance, but they are very slow to attach?
Would you rather be able to see hidden platforms and paths, but they only appear for 1 second at a time, or be able to trigger invisible switches, but you don't know where they are?
Would you rather have your character’s jumps have a slight homing effect towards the goal, but it sometimes leads you into danger, or have your character’s jumps be completely precise, but you have to manually aim every single one?
Would you rather have the ability to create temporary shields that block enemies but also block your own projectiles, or have the ability to push enemies away with a burst of energy, but it also pushes you back?
Would you rather have your character automatically grab onto any ledge within a certain radius, but it sometimes grabs onto the wrong one, or have your character have a magnetic pull that attracts collectibles, but it also attracts enemies?
Would you rather be able to break any barrier with a single punch, but it takes 10 seconds to recharge, or be able to phase through any barrier, but you lose health each time?
Would you rather have your character’s movements be incredibly fluid and graceful, but they are completely uncontrollable, or have your character’s movements be stiff and robotic, but you have absolute precision?
Would you rather have the ability to briefly turn into a ghost, allowing you to float through obstacles but be unable to interact with anything, or have the ability to become super strong for a few seconds, allowing you to break through anything but leaving you exhausted afterward?

Strategy Game Struggles

Would you rather have an army that is incredibly numerous but very weak, or an army that is very small but incredibly powerful?
Would you rather have perfect scouting information about your enemy’s base, but you can never attack their units directly, or have the ability to instantly destroy any enemy unit, but you have no idea where they are?
Would you rather have your economy boom incredibly fast but your research takes forever, or have your research complete instantly but your economy grows very slowly?
Would you rather have units that are immune to damage but have zero attack power, or units that deal massive damage but explode after one hit?
Would you rather be able to control every unit on the map with perfect micromanagement, but have no macro-management abilities, or have perfect macro-management but only be able to control one unit at a time?
Would you rather have a defensive building that makes your base invincible but stops all your units from leaving, or an offensive building that destroys enemy bases instantly but you can’t build any more units?
Would you rather have units that level up extremely quickly but have a very low max level, or units that level up very slowly but have an incredibly high max level?
Would you rather have access to a powerful ultimate ability that can only be used once per game, or have access to a series of smaller, less impactful abilities that can be used frequently?
Would you rather have your opponent’s entire army revealed to you every minute, but you can’t see your own units, or have your own units highlighted, but you have no idea where your opponent is?
Would you rather have units that can terraform the battlefield to your advantage, but they are very slow, or units that can deploy instant fortifications, but they are very fragile?
Would you rather have an AI opponent that is incredibly aggressive and attacks constantly, but makes predictable mistakes, or an AI opponent that plays a perfect defensive game, but never initiates an attack?
Would you rather have the ability to predict your opponent’s next move with 90% accuracy, but you have to sacrifice a unit each time, or have the ability to instantly counter their last move, but it only works 50% of the time?
Would you rather have a faction that has incredibly strong economy but weak military, or an incredibly strong military but a struggling economy?
Would you rather have your units automatically capture any unoccupied objectives on the map, but they also try to capture enemy objectives, or have your units only attack if you directly command them, but they never make mistakes?
Would you rather have a technology tree that allows you to unlock incredibly powerful late-game units, but the early game is almost impossible, or an early game that is incredibly easy, but your late-game units are mediocre?
Would you rather have your spies be able to steal any resource from your enemy, but they are always caught and executed, or have your spies be able to gather information, but it's always outdated by the time you get it?
Would you rather have your units heal automatically over time but at a very slow rate, or have them heal instantly but only when you have a large surplus of a specific resource?
Would you rather have the ability to see through fog of war but your units are always visible, or have your units completely invisible but you can’t see anything on the map?
Would you rather have buildings that automatically repair themselves but take longer to construct, or buildings that construct quickly but require constant manual repair?
Would you rather have a victory condition that is extremely difficult to achieve but guarantees an instant win, or a victory condition that is very easy to achieve but only gives you a slight advantage?

MMO Miracles and Mayhem

Would you rather have infinite gold but never be able to level up, or be max level but have to start every character from scratch with no gear?
Would you rather be able to teleport to any city instantly, but it drains half your mana, or be able to fly over any terrain, but it’s only at walking speed?
Would you rather have every piece of gear you equip be legendary quality but have a 10% chance to break permanently upon logging out, or have all your gear be common quality but never break?
Would you rather be able to talk to all mobs in the game and have them willingly help you, but they are all incredibly annoying and talk non-stop, or be able to mind control any mob for a short period, but they always attack you when the effect wears off?
Would you rather have your character be able to summon an army of loyal but very weak pets, or have your character be able to summon one incredibly powerful but uncontrollable pet?
Would you rather be able to craft any item in the game perfectly, but it takes 24 hours to complete, or be able to craft items instantly, but they always have a random, detrimental stat?
Would you rather be able to see all hidden treasures and quest givers on the map, but you can’t interact with them, or be able to complete any quest you find, but you have no idea where to find them?
Would you rather have your character be able to breathe underwater indefinitely, but you are incredibly slow on land, or be able to run at super speed on land, but you can only hold your breath for 10 seconds underwater?
Would you rather have every player you meet be friendly and willing to help you, but they all talk in riddles, or have every player you meet be hostile and try to kill you, but they offer you amazing loot?
Would you rather have a companion who is a master of every profession, but they are incredibly expensive to maintain, or have a companion who is a master of one profession, but they are free?
Would you rather be able to see enemy health bars and abilities, but your own character’s UI is completely blank, or have your own character’s UI perfectly displayed, but you can’t see anything about your enemies?
Would you rather have your character be able to disguise themselves as any NPC, but they can only stand still while disguised, or be able to charm any enemy, but they constantly beg you for treats?
Would you rather have a mount that is incredibly fast but only works in specific zones, or a mount that works anywhere but is slower than walking?
Would you rather have the ability to instantly kill any player in PvP combat, but you are flagged as a criminal and all guards attack you, or have the ability to become invincible to all PvP damage, but you can’t attack anyone?
Would you rather have your character’s abilities be incredibly powerful but have a very long cooldown, or have your character’s abilities be weak but have no cooldown?
Would you rather have every piece of loot you find be slightly cursed, requiring you to cleanse it or suffer a penalty, or have no loot at all, but all your skills are free to use?
Would you rather be able to instantly learn any new skill by watching someone else do it, but you also gain all their bad habits, or be able to master any skill with dedicated practice, but it takes months of real-time effort?
Would you rather have a trade chat that is always filled with helpful information, but it’s also incredibly noisy and spammy, or have a trade chat that is always quiet and organized, but no one ever wants to trade?
Would you rather have your character be immune to all crowd control effects but take double damage, or be able to resist all damage but be completely vulnerable to crowd control?
Would you rather have the ability to see the future of your character’s progression, but you can’t change any of it, or have the ability to randomly change your character’s stats with each level up, but you have no control over the outcome?

Genre-Bending Brain Teasers

Would you rather be able to control the weather in a survival game, but it always reflects your current mood, or be able to conjure any item you need, but it costs you a happy memory?
Would you rather be able to solve any puzzle in a puzzle game instantly, but you forget the solution immediately after, or be able to solve puzzles with a hint system that always gives you the wrong answer?
Would you rather be able to pilot any vehicle in a racing game at max speed, but you have no steering control, or be able to steer perfectly, but your vehicle is always going uphill?
Would you rather have a dating sim character fall in love with you instantly, but they are incredibly clingy and jealous, or have a dating sim character slowly fall for you, but they are always busy and unavailable?
Would you rather be able to build any structure you can imagine in a building game, but it’s incredibly fragile and falls apart easily, or build incredibly sturdy structures, but you can only use basic geometric shapes?
Would you rather be able to read the minds of your opponents in a strategy card game, but you can only read their thoughts about what they had for breakfast, or be able to see the top 3 cards of their deck, but they are always in reverse order?
Would you rather be able to control time in a rhythm game to perfectly hit every note, but the music plays at half speed, or have the music play at normal speed, but you have to tap each note twice?
Would you rather be able to survive any environment in a horror game without taking damage, but you are constantly haunted by jump scares, or be able to avoid all jump scares, but you take massive damage from everything else?
Would you rather be able to discover new areas in an exploration game by simply wishing for them to appear, but they are always empty and barren, or have incredibly detailed and interesting areas, but they are always guarded by incredibly difficult enemies?
Would you rather have your character in a life simulator have perfect luck in everything they do, but they are completely emotionless, or have your character experience every emotion to the extreme, but they have terrible luck?
Would you rather be able to command an army of sentient toasters in a real-time strategy game, or command a fleet of pirate ships that can only sail on land?
Would you rather have a stealth game character who can turn invisible, but their shadow is always visible and extremely bright, or a character who can move silently, but they leave a trail of glitter everywhere they go?
Would you rather be able to summon a powerful magical artifact in a puzzle game, but it only works once and disappears, or be able to use a set of minor magical tools that recharge quickly but are very weak?
Would you rather have a simulation game where you manage a zoo filled with mythical creatures, but they are all incredibly lazy, or manage a zoo filled with normal animals, but they all have opera singing voices?
Would you rather be able to talk to any animal in a pet simulator, but they only speak in existential poetry, or have animals that are incredibly intelligent and can perform complex tasks, but they are completely uncontrollable?
Would you rather have a fighting game character who can instantly KO their opponent, but they lose health with every move, or a character who takes no damage but has incredibly weak attacks?
Would you rather be able to see the future of your character’s destiny in a visual novel, but it’s always a negative outcome, or be able to choose your own destiny, but you have no idea what the consequences will be?
Would you rather have a sports game where you are a star player with perfect skills, but the opposing team is also impossibly good, or a game where the opposing team is incredibly incompetent, but your own skills are average?
Would you rather be able to hack into any system in a cyberpunk game, but it always triggers a silent alarm, or be able to disable all security systems, but you can’t move while you do it?
Would you rather have a sandbox game where you have infinite resources but no goals, or a game with very limited resources but incredibly clear and engaging objectives?

So, there you have it! Video Game Would You Rather Questions are more than just silly hypotheticals; they’re a way to engage with the games we love on a deeper, more imaginative level. They spark debate, encourage creative thinking, and most importantly, provide endless hours of fun. Keep these questions in mind the next time you're gaming, and you might just discover something new about yourself and your favorite virtual worlds!