73 Biblical Would You Rather Questions

Have you ever played "Would You Rather?" It's a fun game where you have to pick between two silly or tough choices. Well, get ready to dive into a whole new world of choices with Biblical Would You Rather Questions! These questions take the game we love and mix it with stories and characters from the Bible, making you think, laugh, and maybe even learn a little something.

What Are Biblical Would You Rather Questions and Why Are They a Hit?

Biblical Would You Rather Questions are exactly what they sound like: you're presented with two scenarios, both inspired by events, people, or teachings found in the Bible, and you have to choose which one you'd rather experience. They're not just about picking the "easy" option; they're designed to make you consider different aspects of faith, character, and even what it means to follow God. They're super popular because they offer a lighthearted way to engage with important biblical themes without feeling like a lecture. Think of it like this:

They make the Bible relatable to everyday life.
They spark interesting conversations among friends and family.
They can even help you understand biblical stories better by putting yourself in the shoes of the characters.

These questions are used in all sorts of ways. Youth groups might use them for icebreakers, families can play them during car rides, or you might even see them pop up in online forums discussing faith. The goal is always to get people thinking and talking in a fun and engaging manner. The real importance lies in how they encourage deeper thought about biblical narratives and principles. It’s a fantastic way to learn:

By actively making choices, you remember the scenarios more clearly.
You can explore different interpretations of biblical events.
It's a great way to test your understanding of what different biblical characters might have gone through.

Would You Rather Be a Prophet or an Apostle?

Would you rather be Noah, building an ark for 120 years, or Moses, leading the Israelites through the desert for 40 years?
Would you rather have the wisdom of Solomon or the strength of Samson?
Would you rather be David, facing Goliath with just a sling, or Elijah, calling down fire from heaven?
Would you rather be Peter, denying Jesus three times and then being restored, or Judas, betraying Jesus for 30 pieces of silver?
Would you rather be Mary, the mother of Jesus, or Mary Magdalene, a follower who witnessed the resurrection?
Would you rather be John the Baptist, living in the wilderness and eating locusts, or Paul, traveling the world and spreading the Gospel?
Would you rather have the patience of Job, enduring immense suffering, or the faith of Abraham, willing to sacrifice his son?
Would you rather be Ruth, showing loyalty to your mother-in-law and finding a new home, or Esther, risking your life to save your people?
Would you rather be Daniel, surviving a lion's den, or Jonah, being swallowed by a great fish?
Would you rather be an angel delivering a message from God, or a wise man following a star to find the Messiah?
Would you rather be an Israelite during the plagues of Egypt, or a Philistine during the time of Samson?
Would you rather be one of the disciples on the boat with Jesus during the storm, or one of the disciples watching Jesus walk on water?
Would you rather be a Samaritan woman at the well, meeting Jesus, or a blind man Jesus healed?
Would you rather be a shepherd watching over your flock on the night Jesus was born, or a wise man bringing gifts to the infant Jesus?
Would you rather be a Pharisee arguing with Jesus, or a tax collector trying to get a glimpse of him?
Would you rather be a young boy who shared his five loaves and two fish, or a woman who anointed Jesus with expensive perfume?
Would you rather be Barnabas, encouraging others, or Timothy, working closely with Paul?
Would you rather be a believer in the early church facing persecution, or a modern-day believer living in a peaceful land?
Would you rather be one of the women who discovered the empty tomb, or one of the men who saw Jesus after his resurrection?
Would you rather have the courage of Stephen, the first martyr, or the perseverance of Paul, enduring shipwrecks and imprisonment?

Would You Rather Live During the Exodus or the Exile?

Would you rather be part of the Israelites crossing the Red Sea, or part of the Israelites building the second temple?
Would you rather be in Egypt during the Ten Plagues, or in Babylon during the time of Daniel?
Would you rather be a slave in Egypt, or a captive in Babylon?
Would you rather be one of the spies sent into Canaan, or one of the wanderers in the wilderness?
Would you rather be a judge in Israel during the time of Deborah, or a king during the time of David?
Would you rather be a prophet warning the people of coming judgment, or a priest serving in the temple?
Would you rather be a person living in Jerusalem before its destruction, or a person in exile trying to make a new life?
Would you rather be a woman who experienced childbirth during the Exodus, or a woman raising children during the exile?
Would you rather be a musician playing at King David's coronation, or a musician playing the harp in Babylon?
Would you rather be a craftsman helping to build the Tabernacle, or a craftsman helping to build the Temple?
Would you rather be a farmer struggling with drought during the wilderness wandering, or a farmer trying to grow crops in exile?
Would you rather be a young person taught the Law in the wilderness, or a young person taught the Law in Babylon?
Would you rather be one of the first generation to enter the Promised Land, or one of the generation that returned from exile?
Would you rather be a leader trying to keep the people united during the Exodus, or a leader trying to keep faith alive during the exile?
Would you rather be a person blessed with manna from heaven, or a person blessed with provisions in a foreign land?
Would you rather be someone experiencing God's direct intervention in the wilderness, or someone clinging to faith through difficult circumstances?
Would you rather be present at the giving of the Ten Commandments, or present at the reading of the rebuilt Law?
Would you rather be a traveler on the Exodus journey, or a traveler returning to Jerusalem?
Would you rather be a person who witnessed miracles daily, or a person who relied solely on God's promises?
Would you rather be someone facing the unknown dangers of the wilderness, or someone facing the uncertainty of a new beginning in a foreign land?

Would You Rather Hear Directly From Jesus or Read His Word?

Would you rather have Jesus personally give you the Sermon on the Mount to memorize, or have to read it in the Gospel of Matthew later?
Would you rather be one of the disciples walking with Jesus and hearing his parables firsthand, or be a believer today reading those parables?
Would you rather have Jesus heal you with a touch, or have to believe in His healing power through reading His promises?
Would you rather hear Jesus pray for you before the cross, or read the prayers He prayed for His disciples?
Would you rather have Jesus call you by name to follow Him, like Peter and Andrew, or be called to follow Him through reading the Gospels?
Would you rather witness the feeding of the 5,000 with Jesus present, or read the account of it in scripture?
Would you rather have Jesus tell you, "Follow me," directly, or feel His call through the inspiration of the Holy Spirit and scripture?
Would you rather be one of the women at the tomb who heard the angel say, "He is not here; He has risen!" or read their testimony in the Bible?
Would you rather have Jesus speak to you from heaven, as Paul experienced, or read Paul's letters describing his encounters?
Would you rather be taught directly by Jesus about the Kingdom of God, or learn about it through the teachings of His apostles in the New Testament?
Would you rather have Jesus tell you personally to forgive your enemies, or read His teachings on forgiveness?
Would you rather be present when Jesus calmed the storm and hear Him say, "Peace, be still!" or read about His power over nature?
Would you rather have Jesus rebuke your doubts directly, or find comfort and correction in His written word?
Would you rather be a listener at the Transfiguration, hearing God's voice declare Jesus as His Son, or read the account of it?
Would you rather have Jesus explain a difficult parable to you privately, or study it with commentaries and theological insights?
Would you rather be one of the first to hear Jesus' beatitudes spoken, or read them in the context of the Sermon on the Mount?
Would you rather have Jesus personally commission you to preach the Gospel, or feel that commission through reading the Great Commission?
Would you rather hear Jesus say, "Your sins are forgiven," directly to you, or find assurance of forgiveness in His promises?
Would you rather be in the Upper Room when Jesus instituted the Lord's Supper and hear His words, or participate in communion today?
Would you rather have Jesus tell you, "I am the way, the truth, and the life," face to face, or believe it through the Gospel of John?

Would You Rather Be a Disciple on the Road to Emmaus or Paul on the Road to Damascus?

Would you rather be Cleopas, walking with Jesus (unrecognized) on the road to Emmaus, or Paul, struck down by blinding light on the road to Damascus?
Would you rather be one of the disciples watching Jesus ascend into heaven, or be one of the disciples receiving the Holy Spirit at Pentecost?
Would you rather be a soldier guarding the tomb of Jesus, or a woman discovering the empty tomb?
Would you rather be a fisherman who dropped everything to follow Jesus, or a tax collector who did the same?
Would you rather be John the Apostle, leaning on Jesus' breast at the Last Supper, or Peter, denying Jesus three times?
Would you rather be a woman healed of bleeding for twelve years by touching Jesus' garment, or a man whose demon-possessed son was healed by Jesus?
Would you rather be a Pharisee who argued with Jesus about the Sabbath, or a tax collector named Zacchaeus who was called down from a tree by Jesus?
Would you rather be a centurion whose servant Jesus healed from afar, or a rich young ruler who turned away from Jesus because of his possessions?
Would you rather be Mary, the mother of Jesus, holding Him as an infant, or Mary Magdalene, seeing Him risen from the dead?
Would you rather be the boy who shared his five loaves and two fish, or the person who received healing from the miracle?
Would you rather be a prophet like Elijah, calling fire from heaven, or Elisha, performing many miracles in Elijah's stead?
Would you rather be an Israelite in the wilderness, seeing God's provision with manna, or a Gentile receiving the Gospel in the early church?
Would you rather be a wise man following the star to Bethlehem, or a shepherd hearing the angels sing on the plains?
Would you rather be a man like Job, tested by suffering, or a man like Joseph, tested by betrayal and slavery?
Would you rather be a queen like Esther, risking your life for your people, or a loyal friend like Ruth, sticking by your mother-in-law?
Would you rather be a king like David, known for his faith and his flaws, or a king like Hezekiah, known for his righteousness?
Would you rather be a builder of the Tabernacle, following God's detailed instructions, or a worshipper at the Temple in Jerusalem?
Would you rather be a psalm writer, pouring out your heart to God, or a proverb writer, sharing wisdom for daily life?
Would you rather be a messenger like Gabriel, delivering divine news, or a follower like Luke, recording God's work?
Would you rather be a believer in Antioch, where followers were first called Christians, or a believer in Corinth, dealing with church problems?

Would You Rather Be Famous for Faith or Famous for Deeds?

Would you rather be remembered for your unwavering faith like Abraham, or for your mighty deeds like Samson?
Would you rather be known for your prayer life like Daniel, or for your wisdom like Solomon?
Would you rather be celebrated for your obedience like Noah, or for your passion like Peter?
Would you rather be lauded for your humility like Moses, or for your boldness like Paul?
Would you rather be revered for your patience like Job, or for your forgiveness like Jesus?
Would you rather be noted for your love like David, or for your courage like Gideon?
Would you rather be recognized for your generosity like Ruth, or for your compassion like Dorcas?
Would you rather be honored for your diligence like the ant, or for your perseverance like the early church?
Would you rather be admired for your integrity like Joseph, or for your faithfulness like Enoch?
Would you rather be praised for your hospitality like the widow of Zarephath, or for your courage like Esther?
Would you rather be marked for your service like the Levites, or for your leadership like Joshua?
Would you rather be celebrated for your understanding of scripture like Apollos, or for your preaching like John the Baptist?
Would you rather be remembered for your willingness to sacrifice like Abraham, or for your willingness to serve like Jesus?
Would you rather be known for your prophetic voice like Isaiah, or for your practical wisdom like Solomon?
Would you rather be honored for your dedication to God like Hannah, or for your unwavering trust like Jeremiah?
Would you rather be celebrated for your ability to lead like David, or for your ability to inspire like Barnabas?
Would you rather be recognized for your love of God's law like Ezra, or for your love of people like Jesus?
Would you rather be remembered for your intercessory prayer like Moses, or for your courageous witness like Stephen?
Would you rather be lauded for your obedience to God's commands like Joshua, or for your willingness to suffer for righteousness like the apostles?
Would you rather be praised for your devotion like Mary, the mother of Jesus, or for your transformation like the woman at the well?

Would You Rather Witness a Miracle or Perform One?

Would you rather witness Jesus walk on water, or walk on water yourself?
Would you rather witness Jesus feed 5,000 people with five loaves and two fish, or be the one to provide the food for the miracle?
Would you rather witness the Red Sea parting for the Israelites, or be one of the Israelites to walk across on dry land?
Would you rather witness Elijah calling fire from heaven, or be Elijah calling fire from heaven?
Would you rather witness Jesus raise Lazarus from the dead, or be Lazarus raised from the dead?
Would you rather witness the walls of Jericho fall after a trumpet blast, or be one of the trumpet players?
Would you rather witness Jesus heal a blind man with mud and spit, or be the blind man healed?
Would you rather witness Daniel survive the lion's den, or be Daniel surviving the lion's den?
Would you rather witness the sun stand still for Joshua, or be Joshua asking the sun to stand still?
Would you rather witness the waters of the Jordan River part for Joshua, or be one of the priests carrying the Ark of the Covenant?
Would you rather witness Jesus calm a storm at sea with a word, or be one of the disciples on the boat?
Would you rather witness the miraculous catch of fish for Peter and the other disciples, or be the one to make that incredible catch?
Would you rather witness Elisha make an axe head float, or be the one whose axe head floated?
Would you rather witness the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah by fire and brimstone, or be Lot's wife who looked back?
Would you rather witness the burning bush speaking to Moses, or be Moses hearing God's voice from the bush?
Would you rather witness the dove descending on Jesus at His baptism, or be Jesus being baptized?
Would you rather witness the healing of the paralytic lowered through the roof, or be the paralytic being healed?
Would you rather witness Peter raise Tabitha from the dead, or be Tabitha raised from the dead?
Would you rather witness the pillars of the temple fall to defeat Samson, or be Samson bringing down the pillars?
Would you rather witness the angel smite the firstborn of Egypt, or be one of the Israelites protected by the blood of the lamb?

Would You Rather Be a King or a Shepherd?

Would you rather be King David, tending sheep in your youth and then ruling a nation, or be a shepherd who stayed with your flock your whole life?
Would you rather be King Solomon, known for your wisdom and wealth, or be a simple farmer living in the land of Canaan?
Would you rather be King Saul, chosen by God but later disobedient, or be Samuel, the prophet who anointed kings?
Would you rather be King Hezekiah, a good king who faced a great army, or be Isaiah, a prophet who advised King Hezekiah?
Would you rather be King Nebuchadnezzar, building a great empire, or Daniel, a captive who served the king faithfully?
Would you rather be King Herod, who wanted to kill baby Jesus, or Joseph, Jesus' earthly father?
Would you rather be King Agrippa, who was almost persuaded to be a Christian, or Paul, who actively preached to him?
Would you rather be a queen like Esther, ruling a kingdom and saving your people, or a humble servant who helped Esther?
Would you rather be a ruler who has to make tough decisions for your people, or a shepherd who cares for a small flock?
Would you rather be a king who enjoys feasts and luxury, or a shepherd who lives a simple life in the fields?
Would you rather be a ruler who is constantly worried about enemies and power, or a shepherd who worries about wolves and weather?
Would you rather be King Josiah, restoring the Law and leading religious reform, or a priest serving in the Temple during his reign?
Would you rather be a king who is celebrated for your conquests, or a shepherd who is known for your gentle care of animals?
Would you rather be a ruler who has great responsibility and pressure, or a shepherd who has freedom and peace?
Would you rather be a king who is surrounded by advisors, or a shepherd who relies on your own instincts?
Would you rather be King Solomon, building a magnificent temple, or a craftsman who helped build that temple?
Would you rather be a king who is called "friend of God," or a shepherd who is among the first to hear about the birth of Jesus?
Would you rather be a ruler who is asked difficult questions about justice, or a shepherd who is asked simple questions about the sheep?
Would you rather be King Joash, who was hidden as a child to save him, or the priest Jehoiada who raised him?
Would you rather be a king who fears God, or a shepherd who loves God's creation?

So there you have it – a whole bunch of Biblical Would You Rather Questions to get your brain buzzing! Whether you're picking between ancient prophets, pondering impossible choices, or imagining yourself in a Bible story, these questions are a fun way to connect with the Bible. They remind us that the stories in scripture are full of real people facing tough decisions, and they encourage us to think about what we value and how we would respond. Keep asking, keep thinking, and keep exploring the amazing stories of the Bible!